Apologies if this is a bit obvious but working with trial version and hit a stumbling block.
I have an image looking out to sea over green grass, blue sea to horizon and overcast cloudy sky. Try as i might I’m not able to enhance just the sky area to bring out the colour blue. I can do the entire image but that’s not what I want.
I may be missing the obvious or not understanding some of the DXO terminology but any help would be appreciated.
Clear View makes it a bit “bluer” but nowhere near enough. Gradient Filter doesn’t seem to allow manipulation of a single colour within the gradient area.
Struggling to get U Point to do very much, seems to be wanting to adjust within the defined shap. I want to enhance the blue sky at various points in image.
If your hope was that there is a color picker that would allow you to paint in a specific color to turn the sky from grey to blue, that functionality does not exist in PhotoLab. Using local adjustment you can change things like exposure, vibrancy, saturation, temperature, tint and hue which can have a major impact on the color of the sky,
With the multiple large u-points, there is usually some kind of automated luminous selection enabled (the luminous of whatever user selects first will be the starting point for the selection). When you link multiple u-points like this, it’s possible to do a sort of luminous mask/selection and affect the whole set.
Here’s a quick example of two big linked U-points used to turn a sky green (I’d turn it steely blue but then someone might think that those colours are either in the sky or in the buildings to begin with - green shows more clearly).
I used the sky luminous map to bring the sky way down so I could increase the overall exposure fairly radically. I could probably do more to highlight the nun (a mask on her to increase brightness and add a bit of clarity). But I’m fine with this.
I’m processing from the jpeg this time as it’s a Fuji X-T3 file (what I happen to have with me and want to process right now). DxO PhotoLab is surprisingly subtle in its treatment of jpegs. Looking at the full size copy, I see I should have added the exclude mask on the clock tower as the edge is very hot and on the edge of the roof to its left as well. Up to 2048 pixels (500px, Facebook), it’s fine as is.
The local adjustment tools are already very powerful, even if they are different than the masks we would apply in Photoshop or Affinity Photo.
Your example works well, Alec, when there’s some cloud detail in the sky - but, when the sky is “bland and flat” then it would be great to be able to use the Graduated Filter (in Local Adjustments) to apply some blue colourisation … as per the request mentioned above.
I voted for your gradient filter request. The issue here is that the original poster @mandarin Michael Clift was struggling to recolour his skies. My post was to show him how to do so with the existing U-point local adjustment tools. There’s no urgent need for tool improvement here to be able to effectively and efficiently recolour skies or water.
I think we’re all getting a bit spoiled here and losing sight of the end goal - a great RAW developer which works fast and efficiently. It’s absurd to expect DxO to bring most of Photoshop into PhotoLab and still maintain reasonable performance (make sure to read @Garret’s post a little lower as well).
That is a fair comment Alec but it is also the reason that DxO will never be my front line editor. Lr just brings so much power to the table and in one place. I really do not see any over-riding reason to go to DxO first; the difference in image quality argument does not cut it for me and I still think the out of the box images in Lr are superior in the main.
A big thank you to all those that responded with helpful suggestions.
With the use of U points and a lot of tinkering i was able to get close to what i wanted to achieve. Guess it’s a question of more practise needed.
The effects in Nix are quite interesting and i like the way you can assign them in “Open in Application”. However the Nix interface is very difficult to follow with light grey text on the dark background and no obvious way to adjust. Also a bit disappointing that only seems to want to work on jpg files, not a lot of use when you shoot in Raw.
I’ve still got a few days in trial mode to get better acquainted with the software.
Will I buy it?
Nix - no I wouldn’t, too fiddly to use, difficult to read legends, and most of it of no real use if you have PL2.
PL2 - most of what it does it does well but at full price it’s a lot of money for the full set. I’ll make a decision when trial ends and i’ve played a bit more.
Again, support here has been tremendous. Unfortunately the couple of questions i sent to DXO Support whilst answered pretty quick were quite vague and nowhere near the quality and detail of forum responses.