I’m about 90% sure I’m going to leave Adobe and use PhotoLab. However, in an effort to save internal SSD space, I’m wondering if it’s possible to use PhotoLab like Pure Raw, and first demosaic/denoise my files and create the compressed .dng (and offload my original RAWs to an external drive just for backup). My workflow would look like:
Load RAWs to a folder on my computer
Use PhotoLab to batch demosaic/denoise, save .DNGs in same folder
Offload RAWs to external drive
Edit .DNGs
I’m wondering if this is possible or if I have to double dip and get Pure Raw as well as PhotoLab?
mwsilvers
(Mark - New Jersey, USA, Win10, RTX 4060, PL9, FP8, VP5, Nikon Zf )
2
When exporting to DNG, besides applying DeepPRIME NR before export you also need to apply optical corrections including Lens distortion, chromatic aberration, vignetting, and lens sharpness optimization. In addition, if you also have a Viewpoint license you can apply Volume Deformation.
PureRAW is a subset of PhotoLab, so yes you can use PhotoLab like PureRAW.
However if you have no intention of ever using the many additional editing features of PL to complete the editing of your image then it makes little sense to buy PL.
If you are ditching Adobe, what are you going to use to edit the .dng files you create?
mwsilvers
(Mark - New Jersey, USA, Win10, RTX 4060, PL9, FP8, VP5, Nikon Zf )
5
Did you understand my earlier post about the importance of also applying optical corrections to your raw files, in addition to DeepPrime NR, before you export to DNG.?
I have no experience of using DNGs of any type but I presume you want to export to compressed DNGs in order to save disk space. Surely though by retaining the RAWs and creating matching DNGs you will use more disk space?
I don’t know for sure but I think the lowest disk space footprint workflow you can do with PL is:
Open RAW in PL
Apply *all edits
Of course you would need a third step, export to a pixel based format (TIFF/JPEG/etc.) if you wished to share you finished image with others or if you wanted to do further editing in a pixel based editor (Photoshop / Affinity/ etc.)
I tried it. Oof, it’s not easy doing it in PhotoLab. Filtering an album by ISO isn’t possible, and the search function searches ALL images, not just the album or sub folder I’m in. So if I want to denoise all images with ISO 800-1600 with these settings, and 1600-6400 with those settings, you have to go one-by-one and and color tag or star them, denoise one image, copy the settings, then paste them to the others. It’s super frustrating.
Within the folders, you can sort images by ISO value.
It’s also important to know that noise reduction in PhotoLab takes into account both the ISO value and the image content. For example, in an image taken at low ISO but with dark areas, the noise reduction process adapts to the image’s content. Most importantly, the slider settings adjust to the ISO values: the same setting (for example, luminance = 40) will not produce the same noise reduction results if the image is taken at low ISO versus high ISO. If you are not limited by the processing power of your equipment, you can leave the choice of processing (DeepPRIME 3 or DeepPRIME XD3) for all your regular images.
I have heard this before but have never seen any evidence of this happening. I have to manually change the Luminance value otherwise it always stays the same. I have never seen automatic changes in noise reduction - does it happen under the hood? If so what is the point of having a luminance value that you can change? AmI misunderstanding the luminance value? Does it determine the amount of noise reduction? It certainly seems to?
I can confirm that noise reduction automatically adjusts to ISO values!
There’s no need to adjust the sliders in general. The luminance value of 40 is the default standard value: it won’t provide the same noise reduction at ISO 100 as it does at ISO 32,000.
These settings are only relevant if you need to fine-tune one (or more) images.
You can also change the values for all photos as you wish: this will globally modify the amount/quality of noise reduction. But the principle remains the same: a correction value of 30, for example, will always adapt to the ISO values of each image.
It helped me find the right balance between noise reduction and residual noise (sometimes I prefer a little more noise). But this is less needed with DeepprimeXD3 which leaves a more “pleasing” amount of noise where I would like it.
The default value does not change (40 for me), but noise reduction adapts itself anyway in different zone of the image or with different images.
There are 2 “components” in noise reduction : chrominance and luminance.
Take a very high iso shot (everything will be obvious with it).
Uncheck noise reduction and zoom at 100 %. You’ll see that noise is colourful. When applying noise reduction, color noise and luminance noise are “corrected”. Apply Deepprime XD2 and play with the luminance slider from 0 to 100 and you will see little or lot of noise reduction applied on luminance noise component when color noise component is fortunately always corrected.
EDIT : Luminance noise helps to find a right balance in conjunction with lens sharpness optimisation setting too, depending of the subject (I find faces in low light for example needs more tweaking and balance between those 2 settings).
I always tweak luminance noise in conjunction with lens sharpness optimization.
Sure - I get all that - it was a rhetorical question - my point is that it doesn’t autocorrect the noise dependant on the amount of noise in the image or the ISO as is sometimes suggested - you have to manually correct the noise to taste - hence the luminance slider - It doesn’t matter how much noise is in the image nor what the ISO is the default 40 luminance is always used unless you select a preset. Some people are suggesting that it automatically sets the noise reduction - it doesn’t
Since you want to use compressed DNGs exported by DxO to conserve storage space, it’s essential to decide what apps you’ll use to edit those files and test them. Some apps.(e.g. Adobe apps) can open and process DxO compressed DNGs, but others (e.g. Topaz Labs apps) cannot. Topaz works fine with DxO’s full-size DNGs, but does not support DxO’s compressed DNGs.
If this follow-up question has been discussed in other PL10 threads, I missed it and apologize for the duplication.
Early versions of PL9 supported the export of DNGs with all corrections applied back to Lightroom Classic, but that ability was removed somewhere around PL9.6. PureRaw has continued to support DNG export.
Was DNG export with all corrections applied restored in PL10?