DXO Softwares on LINUX ! (please .....)

So you have chosen to double down: here are arguments as promised then.
Let’s address this point and then go back up a bit.
First I’ll make an analogy.
PhotoLab supports X-Trans CMOS from Fujifilm since version 5, and in Elite versions only: it took them a lot of time to implement it.
Last year, all Fujifilm cameras combined (so, including other sensors than X-Trans) only amounted to 6% of the digital camera market.
Did DxO waste their time supporting an arcane RAW format from a very special sensor from a brand that only has “a few lousy procent” [sic] of the market?

If you say “yes” to that, then your viewpoint about operating system support is coherent, except that in this data Fujifilm only grew +0.2pts (+3.4%) between 2022 and 2024, whereas the Linux market share grew +2.7pts (+75%) to 6.3% in two years according to the annual PornHub stats (yeah I wanted another source than StatCounter), and if their stats are a mean of the whole year then they don’t represent the whole new users from the past few months: Zorin OS, one of the many “mainstream” distributions, announced last month that in less than a month their latest version got downloaded more than 780 000 times from Windows machines, an absolute record.

Do you “see and understand” now?

That being said, as promised, let’s rewind a bit.

It’s Torvalds, not Torwalds.
The official stats only go back to 2005, but if you’re just counting the kernel it had more than 42 000 individual contributors and almost 5 000 organizations contributing to it: it went way beyond the “student project” it once was.

The outcome? See for yourself : 100% of supercomputers, >70% of smartphones (because Android is Linux-based), >63% of web servers, most if not all “smart” devices (like your television, your Internet box, …), and more.
It doesn’t need much to fully bleed onto the desktop.

The software division of IBM and what was its consumer hardware division are completely different, so the loss of one didn’t impact the other, nor their investments into various standards such as the ones described earlier.

Again, when I described WebAssembly versions it only meant that they can run in a browser, whether the source is local or distant doesn’t change that fact.
You can open local files in your browser, you know?
A lot of desktop softwares nowadays are basically a browser with a web application bundled into it (like Visual Studio Code), and the WASM overhead compared to native code isn’t that big (it depends on the language).

It’s Torvalds, not Thorvalds.
As stated previously, MS Office and (part of?) Adobe suites are available online under Linux.
Recently, Microsoft Xbox stopped exclusivity of their games and published them on PlayStation too, because many divisions inside Microsoft don’t care that much where you run their products as long as you pay for them and run them: it’s not far-fetched to imagine a native Linux version of Office, even if as described above their web versions work very well for the special cases where they’re needed (mostly online collaborations anyway).
You should read Torvald’s biography, he didn’t have a “student-like dream”, he just started a project to learn about OSes and provide a free alternative to Unix to his fellow students, and he stayed with the project as it grew alongside him: if the project wasn’t worth it anymore he’d have retired.
The alternatives I suggest work for most people, for the administrations and state services in Europe that made the switch (more are planning to do it), and for the businesses that can use them.
If they don’t work for you, well… don’t use them, or contribute/invest in them?

Oh, a quick reply for another poster.

Darktable and RawTherapee have been mentioned in this thread already.
I’ve started to use both, and they both have their strengths: RawTherapee probably wins on the UI front though.
After checking them out both I don’t think there is a need for more software like these.

As for what I did for them? This week I helped them support the Sony A7V RAWs (only the lossless one for now), and after a quick file replacement I can already edit these RAWs in Darktable: meanwhile the support for this camera is only planned for “a bit later after January” in DxO applications.

You’re welcome.

Or both, when a company needs to sell “vendor-supported operating system” to a client (in web hosting for instance).

Companies need to pay smart people whether they have a Linux or a Microsoft infrastructure (often it’s a mix of both), a Linux infrastructure in itself doesn’t imply paying more people.
On the opposite, in my company we manage way more Linux servers than Windows servers and despite that the Linux team is smaller… go figure!

Now back to Stenis.

On the latest Steam Survey, 3.2% of Steam users are currently on Linux.
And you know what Steam users do? They PAY for games.
My public profile currently lists 2697 games (some of my games are hidden from the public list for “reasons”), so yeah I paid a bunch.
And indeed most of these games run on Linux now, some through native versions and others because Valve invested in compatibility layers.

This thread has many examples of current or former DxO clients who aren’t asking DxO to open-source their software and turn them “donationware” the Blender way (that would probably be stupid): no, we’re asking a Linux version to be able to continue to give them a share of our own money, while showing them the adoption trends and the other benefits they could gain by refactoring their UI (as the core components are already or can be turned platform-agnostic), so the point is that we are willing to pay for a version we can use and which would, in an ideal scenario, work better for everybody while requiring less work on their end in the long run.

Oh and by the way I mentioned Blender: in 2024 they got more than 3 Million euros of income through various donations (including corporate ones): the development fund by itself is currently at almost 250 000 € per month now, for a software that is completely free.
Another example would be KDE, one of the two major desktop environments in Linux: their yearly fundraiser just reached 300 000 €, almost six times what they got last year, for a software that is completely free and only used by a part of “a few lousy percent”: it proves that the new users are more than ready to pay (and also are receptive to the one-time popup the KDE developers added, to be fair).

Again this is not a way to ask DxO to switch to an open source model, but just a way to counter the “users of open source software are not willing to pay” argument.

Yes, and that reason is called inertia.
What we’re trying to show in this thread, with arguments, is that they should prepare for what’s coming because said inertia will bite them in the ass if a commercial competitor acts before them.

We’ll see! Again I’m favouring local webapps and not remote ones, but I also gave other native possibilities.

Oh, another user.

It’s not necessary anymore since 2003 when DKMS arrived to the kernel thanks to Dell, but generally distributions (from the Debian family, the Red Hat family, the Arch family, …) will handle dependencies on kernel upgrades and recompile silently what’s needed, if needed.

Nobody expects you to.

Are you trying to say that restricting the product audience will hurt it in the long run?
How fitting…

Other ones: VLC is mostly French, as well as ffmpeg (an audio/video library used by almost every video service).

Because you may be uncomfortable with the requirements of Windows 11 that, for many machines, requires a complete hardware upgrade (motherboard, CPU, memory) at a time where memory prices have quadrupled due to OpenAI buying 40% of the world’s supply at once.

Or you may be uncomfortable with the fact that Windows 11 is trying to make you use AI at all costs, or pushes broken updates because 30% of new Windows code is potentially broken AI-written code.

Or you may be uncomfortable with Recall, the Windows 11 tool that takes a screenshot of your screen every five seconds to fill a database for use by their AI Copilot.

Or you may want to have a local user on your machine, which Windows 11 actively fights against, instead of having to login on your machine using an online Microsoft account.

I could go on.

That’s right. Windows users shouldn’t have to use the command-line either, but many of them were forced to do that recently due to a bug in the task manager.

It certainly doesn’t matter what I think or write on this forum about the prospect of DxO PhotoLab appearing on Linux systems. It will or will not happen without me. I don’t care anymore.

And, apparently, no matter how many pages of arguments that @Ruzgfpegk and others write, DxO doesn’t seem to care about PhotoLab on Linux either.

I never thought I Linux thread would get so exiting.

But it has made me think and dig in a lot deeper than I would have normally.

If we start at Win 11, we find some very interesting things. The TCM requirement. TCM is sold as security but it is anything but. Believe it or not, the TCM on your motherboard or CPU will allow third parties to access some of your information - this is partly to do with Governments giving people the right not to use cookies. This issue is, what information are they collecting?

When you set-up your new Win 11 machine you will notice that you have to enter a Microsoft ID, usually an outlook address. This ID is then burnt-on to your CPU and TCM. That is how third party companies will be able to identify you. The information they get from the TCM identifies you!

Those people with Win 11 will notice their machines running more slowly (not faster as we were told). This is because your data is being uploaded to the cloud (for your security of course). That’s why you are not allowed to delete One Drive from your Win 11 system. Your PC is going to become a cloud terminal. Sounds great? When do you think Microsoft will start charging you for all that cloud storage?

So, you could keep Windows 10. You could take that offline. Use PL7, 8 or 9 off line and all your other Windows applications. And you can download Linux Mint and run 2 operating systems. Mint could be your online system, for browsing, there are very good office apps that behaves very similarly to MS Office and create docx documents. And you can use Win 10 (offline) to run all your existing apps. If you keep Win 10 offline, MS cannot update and kill it and there is no way for someone to exploit the lack of support.

I have never used Linux - it was way too quirky for me but looking at Youtube video showing Linux Mint - it looks pretty much like Win 10, just faster, sleeker, and to a great extent safer. So maybe the answer is to dual boot my PC?

Citation needed, please.

EDITED TO ADD:
I have set up two Win 11 machines with local accounts, i.e. no MS account needed.

Oh and also, you can delete OneDrive.

That only works on Win 11 Pro or Enterprise, most people have the Home version.

Just check out what you are getting into https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C44iCr6czAo

Umm, one of the two Win 11 machines I set up runs the Home version.

Well there are hundreds of videos on Youtube actually showing how you can’t set up a local account on Win 11 Home and you have to self-identify. That’s what the TCM is all about.

Just watch Rob Braxman’s videos on Youtube, he’s been there for 6 years and knows his way around Windows.

So you are saying I dreamt it all when I set up a Win 11 Home machine with a local account?

PS regardless of your answer, I’m done here.

That almost as funny as we’ll agree to disagree.

There are hundreds of videos on Youtube showing people setting up Win 11 Home, and none of them can set up a local account. Maybe you are a genius, All I know is that some very respected Windows specialist on Youtube think that you have to self-identify.

There’s a lot of people who earn their living from selling services and PCs, and Win 11 is very important to them. So the highlighting of privacy problems is problematic. Now maybe you have found a way around it, and if you have I’d recommend posting a video on Youtube and making some decent money out of it.

This is the way to go if you must have windows for something. I recently moved my competent but non-technical wife onto Linux Mint from win10 (not dual boot but I ran dual boot myself for a while). General browsing, emails and finances. She’s very happy (phew!) and notices it’s much quicker than her win10. Linux can read windows files on NTFS but windows can’t read linux ext4.

I think Linux has matured to a point that I would find it usable. Dual booting isn’t easy and on Win 11 is possible but believe it or not Win 11 will keep disabling it, even though you are not asking it to do that. After all, you are just operating a terminal, it’s not really yours any more, the control is with Win 11, you just pay for it.

The issue is photo editing, not so easy on Linux.

The more you read, the more you learn.

It is using Mint (and probably other distros). Dowload an ISO from Mint website. Make a bootable USB stick, burn ISO. Boot from USB stick. Run Mint off USB stick to make sure everything works. Click install and select dual boot from options offered by the installer.

When complete reboot and choose either windows or mint for that session.

The problem I am told is that……………………… wait for it…………………………..

Windows actively tries to destroy your Linux sub-partition. Yep, that’s right. Without your permission. It just does it. There are certain events like changing hard drives/SSDs and the like and it will simply destroy what you have set up.

So I am unsure whether dual boot is the way forward to me and I am unsure whether I need PL. I am not an artistic genius, I have no illusions that I am the next David Bailey (or whoever), my photo editing is usually very basic so do I need PL? I have just watched a video about RapidRAW, it’s very new and basic but runs on all platforms, it has promise and is maybe all I need.

I sent out a few emails to some people who work in the computer industry in the US. Just asking why the big photo editing companies don’t provide a product for Linux. 4 out of 5 said “Microsoft would but their b*lls off if they did. There is zero chance of any of them providing a product for Linux.” So there you have it, don’t wait hoping for change, it won’t happen.

I’ve heard that. All I can say is that when I was dual-booting mint and win10 for a year or so in about 2020/1 it didn’t happen to me. The version of the sorry tale I heard somewhere was that windows update went rogue and broke linux. Or the bootloader. Or both. If true (if!) then presumably win10 should be safe as no more updates (plus win10 is offline).

But you never know, this is Microsft we’re talking about :joy:

It didn’t go rogue. It was deliberate.

Yes, if you are running Win 10 and you take it offline there is nothing MS can do about it.

So I have three main uses for Windows - Office (word and excel), Genealogy (a specific program), and photo editing. So I asked myself can I get the office applications that deal with MS extensions on Linux, it seems I can. Can I use my Gen program on Linux, yep I can. So the last question is photo editing. Do I need DxO? RapidRAW is nowhere near yet but……….. it will get close within a year or so. How much of DxO do I never use? I do like it but do I like it so much that I’ll put up with Windows?

Just ran through RapidRAW, created from open source by an 18 year old Swiss guy (fricking genius if you ask me) in a couple of weeks. It’s meant to be like Lightroom and kind of is, it needs a lot of tweeking but from a standing start, amazing.

The colour science still needs some help but everything else is there. Believe it or not he’s got AI masks! Ok they aren’t brilliant but only 20% below DxO. In a matter of weeks, jeez.

Sorry, but either those videos are wrong or misleading, or your interpretation of them is wrong. You CAN easily set up local accounts, either User or Admin, on Win11 Home Edition during initial installation. I have done it many times.

You’ve done it many times for customers on an enterprise licence?

Thanks for the tip about RapidRaw. I had heard of it before but forgot about it. Looks very promising.

Two ways windows can “break” linux:

Windows fast boot: windows “locks” the disc so linux can’t access the files. Cure: don’t use fast boot, hold SHIFT when shutting down to shut down windows completely.

Windows accesses and corrupts linux files. Windows can’t natively read files on linux ext4 formatted partitions. Cure: don’t install any apps or extensions that enables windows to access ext4 format.

I am almost there now. I have decided not to dual boot. MY wife has a Windows machine with PL7 on, if I desperately need it, it is there. But tomorrow is D-Day. All documents, photos etc will be backed up, the C-Drive will be re-formatted and Linux Mint installed.

If all goes well, I will see you on the other side.